Scroll to turn the page
Economics · AP Microeconomics
prices, elasticity and surplus
A market price is set by no one, and yet it answers who gets the good and who makes it.
The figure is a hypothetical market for pizza slices in a college town: the price in dollars a slice, the quantity in thousands of slices a week. Buyers’ demand slopes down, sellers’ supply slopes up, and they cross at $4.00 and 60 thousand slices.
Walk along the slices from the first to the 60 thousandth. Each was worth more to some buyer than the $4.00 paid (red: consumer surplus), and cost some seller less to make than the $4.00 received (blue: producer surplus). The two areas are what the market is worth to the people in it.
This chapter builds that picture and then uses it: how far buyers and sellers respond to a price (elasticity), what moves the equilibrium, and what taxes, price controls, subsidies, quotas and tariffs do to the two areas. Most of the answers come down to one shape: a triangle of deadweight loss.
This is Unit 2 of AP Microeconomics, 20–25% of the multiple-choice section, and the graph on which most free-response questions are drawn.
the law of demand, and market demand
Demand is the quantity buyers are willing and able to buy at each price, other things equal. The law of demand: a change in a good’s own price changes the quantity demanded the opposite way.
Buyers respond to incentives, such as prices, within constraints: their income, their time, and the law and regulations. And markets need property rights: no one pays for a slice the seller has no right to sell, or a buyer no right to keep.
Why the demand curve slopes down:
A change in price moves buyers along the curve: a change in quantity demanded, never a shift.
Market demand is the sum of every buyer’s demand: at each price, add the quantities across. The figure adds two groups (red and blue) at each price:
| price | $2.00 | $4.00 | $6.00 | $8.00 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| students | 48 | 36 | 24 | 12 |
| office workers | 32 | 24 | 16 | 8 |
| market | 80 | 60 | 40 | 20 |
the determinants of demand
A change in anything but the good’s own price shifts the whole demand curve: an increase in demand (right) or a decrease (left).
The determinants of demand:
In the figure the price stays at $4.00 while the curve moves 30 thousand slices one way or the other: the quantity demanded at $4.00 goes from 60 to 90 or to 30. The figure names the cause each time.
‘Demand’ is the whole curve; ‘quantity demanded’ is one point on it. Keep them apart in every answer: a determinant changes demand; the price changes quantity demanded.
the law of supply, and what shifts it
Supply is the quantity sellers are willing and able to sell at each price. The law of supply: a change in own price changes quantity supplied the same way, a movement along the supply curve.
| price | $2.00 | $3.00 | $4.00 | $5.00 | $6.00 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| quantity supplied | 20 | 40 | 60 | 80 | 100 |
A higher price makes more output worth producing, even as each extra slice costs more to make. Market supply is the sum of every seller’s supply at each price, added across like demand, and it slopes up.
Sellers respond to incentives and technology. The determinants of supply shift the curve:
In the figure the price moves first (along S), then the curve shifts 30 thousand slices each way at $4.00. An increase in supply is a shift right, which on the graph also looks like a shift down: each quantity is offered at a lower price.
the midpoint formula
Price elasticity of demand measures how strongly quantity demanded responds to price: the percentage change in quantity demanded divided by the percentage change in price.
To get the same answer whichever way the price moves, AP uses the midpoint formula: each change is taken as a percentage of the average of the two values.
From $7 to $8, quantity demanded falls from 30 to 20: −10 ÷ 25 = −40.0%, against a price rise of 1 ÷ 7.5 = 13.3%. |Ed| = 3. The same $1 rise from $2 to $3 gives 0.33.
Elasticity is negative for demand; it is read by its size. Greater than 1: elastic; less than 1: inelastic; exactly 1: unit elastic, price and quantity changing in proportion. 0 is perfectly inelastic (a vertical curve); infinite, perfectly elastic (horizontal).
Slope is not elasticity. The line falls $1 for every 10 thousand slices all along, yet the top half is elastic and the bottom half inelastic: high on the line a $1 change is a small percentage of the price and a 10-thousand change a large percentage of a small quantity. At its midpoint, $5.00, it is unit elastic.
Demand is more elastic when there are more close substitutes, when the good takes a larger share of the budget, when it is a luxury rather than a necessity, and over a longer time to adjust.
what a price change does to spending
Total revenue is price × quantity: what sellers take in, and what buyers spend (total expenditure). Which way it moves when the price changes depends on the elasticity of demand.
| P | $1 | $2 | $3 | $4 | $5 | $6 | $7 | $8 | $9 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Qd | 90 | 80 | 70 | 60 | 50 | 40 | 30 | 20 | 10 |
| TR | 90 | 160 | 210 | 240 | 250 | 240 | 210 | 160 | 90 |
The red rectangle in the figure is TR: its height the price, its width the quantity. Raising the price adds height and takes away width; which wins is the elasticity. On the right, TR rises while the slices sold climb through the elastic stretch, peaks where demand is unit elastic, and falls through the inelastic stretch.
So a seller facing inelastic demand earns more by raising the price; one facing elastic demand, by cutting it. It is also why a bumper harvest can leave farmers worse off: demand for food is inelastic.
how far sellers respond
Price elasticity of supply is the percentage change in quantity supplied divided by the percentage change in price. It is positive, since supply slopes up.
The same benchmark of 1: above it supply is elastic, below it inelastic, at it unit elastic. In the pizza market a rise from $4.00 to $5.00 lifts quantity supplied from 60 to 80: by the midpoint formula 28.6% ÷ 22.2% = 1.29, elastic.
The figure turns a supply line through (60, $4.00). Vertical, the quantity cannot change at all: perfectly inelastic (the seats in a stadium tonight). Horizontal, sellers supply any amount at that price and none below: perfectly elastic. Between, a straight supply line is unit elastic if it runs through the origin, elastic if it meets the price axis, inelastic if it meets the quantity axis.
Supply is more elastic when sellers can switch inputs and output easily:
income and cross-price
Elasticity can be measured for any determinant of demand or supply, not just the good’s own price. Two matter most.
Income elasticity of demand = % change in quantity demanded ÷ % change in income. Its sign tells normal from inferior goods: positive, a normal good; negative, an inferior good. Above 1, demand grows faster than income: a luxury. A hypothetical survey, after incomes rise 10%:
| good | quantity demanded when income rises 10% | income elasticity | |
|---|---|---|---|
| meals out | +15% | 1.5 | normal, a luxury |
| bread | +3% | 0.3 | normal, a necessity |
| bus rides | −5% | −0.5 | inferior |
Cross-price elasticity of demand = % change in quantity demanded of one good ÷ % change in the price of another. Positive: substitutes (the dearer good sends buyers to this one). Negative: complements (used together, so a dearer one cuts demand for both). Zero: unrelated. When coffee rises 10%:
| good | quantity demanded when coffee rises 10% | cross-price elasticity | |
|---|---|---|---|
| tea | +6% | 0.6 | substitute |
| cream | −4% | −0.4 | complement |
| pencils | 0% | 0 | unrelated |
With these, as with price elasticity, divide the percentage change in the quantity by the percentage change in the cause. Only the sign is kept here: it is the answer.
equilibrium, and what trade is worth
At the equilibrium price, quantity demanded equals quantity supplied: buyers want to buy exactly what sellers want to sell, and the market clears.
Here P* = $4.00 and Q* = 60 thousand: 100 − 10(4) = 60 = −20 + 20(4). The price carries information: a rising price tells sellers to make more and buyers to economize, steering resources to where they are valued most.
Consumer surplus is what buyers would have been willing to pay minus what they pay: the area under demand and above the price. The figure walks the slices: each red line is one buyer’s surplus, the height of demand (the most they would pay) above $4.00.
Producer surplus is what sellers receive minus the least they would accept: the area above supply and below the price.
The quantity is in thousands of slices a week, so the areas are in thousands of dollars a week. Read each triangle’s height off the price axis: from the price to where the curve meets that axis.
total surplus, and deadweight loss
Total surplus, consumer plus producer, is greatest at the competitive equilibrium. In the absence of market failures, a perfectly competitive market is efficient.
Read demand as the marginal benefit of each slice and supply as its marginal cost. Every slice up to Q* is worth more to a buyer than it costs to make, and each adds the gap between the curves to total surplus. Past Q*, each slice costs more than it is worth.
The surplus lost either way, $30 thousand here, is the deadweight loss: the red triangle between the curves. It goes to no one. That one triangle is how the rest of this chapter measures what a policy costs.
Efficiency here means allocative efficiency: the quantity at which marginal benefit equals marginal cost. It says nothing about whether the split between buyers and sellers is fair.
shortages, surpluses, and elasticity
Away from equilibrium the market is in disequilibrium, and market forces push the price back. A change in a determinant moves the equilibrium itself.
In the figure demand rises by 30 thousand slices at every price in two markets. At the old $4.00 each now has a shortage of 30, and the price climbs until it is gone. How far it climbs depends on supply:
A shift changes consumer and producer surplus too. If demand for pizza itself rises by 30, the equilibrium moves to $5.00 and 80 thousand: consumer surplus goes from $180 to $320 thousand (measured under the new demand curve) and producer surplus from $90 to $160 thousand.
On every graph: shift the curve, label the old and new price and quantity, and read the change off the axes. The size of the change depends on the elasticities of demand and supply.
a legal price, and what it costs
A price ceiling is a legal maximum price; a price floor, a legal minimum. Each matters only if it is binding: a ceiling below the equilibrium price, a floor above it.
A ceiling of $3.00 (rent control is one): quantity demanded 70, quantity supplied 40, a shortage of 30. Only 40 thousand slices are sold, since sellers cannot be made to sell more.
A floor of $5.00 (a minimum wage is one, in the market for labor): quantity supplied 80, quantity demanded 50, a surplus of 30. Only 50 thousand are bought.
| consumer surplus | producer surplus | government | deadweight loss | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| no control | $180 | $90 | – | $0 |
| ceiling $3.00 | $200 | $40 | – | $30 |
| floor $5.00 | $125 | $137.5 | – | $7.5 |
The ceiling helps the buyers who still get a slice (consumer surplus rises from $180 to $200 thousand) at sellers’ expense, and the slices between 40 and 60 thousand are lost: a deadweight loss of $30 thousand. The floor moves surplus the other way, and loses $7.5 thousand. (The table assumes the slices go to the buyers who value them most; queues and luck make a ceiling cost more.)
Set on a market already producing the efficient quantity, a price control, a quantity control, a tax or a subsidy can only reduce allocative efficiency. The deadweight loss is that loss, borne by buyers and sellers together.
a per-unit tax and its deadweight loss
A per-unit (excise) tax drives a wedge between the price buyers pay and the price sellers keep. Taxes change incentives: here they shift supply.
Put a tax of $3.00 a slice on sellers. To supply any quantity they now need $3.00 more, so supply shifts up by the tax. The new equilibrium is where the shifted curve meets demand:
Tax revenue = tax × quantity = $3.00 × 40 thousand = $120 thousand, the rectangle between the two prices. The red triangle is the deadweight loss: ½ × 3 × (60 − 40) = $30 thousand.
| consumer surplus | producer surplus | government | deadweight loss | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| no tax | $180 | $90 | – | $0 |
| tax $3.00 | $80 | $40 | +$120 | $30 |
Check it: 80 + 40 + 120 + 30 = 270, the old total surplus. Buyers and sellers lose more than the government collects.
A tax on buyers instead shifts demand down by $3.00 and gives the same quantity, the same two prices and the same areas. Who writes the check does not decide who pays.
the less elastic side pays more
The incidence of a tax, who bears it, depends on the elasticities of demand and supply. The side that responds less to price, the less elastic one, bears more of the tax.
In the pizza market, of the $3.00 tax buyers pay $2.00 more ($4.00 → $6.00) and sellers keep $1.00 less ($4.00 → $3.00). Here supply is the flatter, more elastic curve, so buyers bear the larger share.
The figure puts the same $3.00 tax on two markets that start at the same point:
At the extremes, perfectly inelastic demand puts the whole tax on buyers, and perfectly inelastic supply the whole tax on sellers; in both, quantity does not fall and there is no deadweight loss. That is why governments tax goods like gasoline and cigarettes: inelastic demand raises revenue with little lost trade.
Subsidies divide the same way: the less elastic side gets more of the benefit.
too much, and too little
A per-unit subsidy pays sellers for each unit, shifting supply down (right) by the subsidy. A quota caps the quantity that may be sold.
A subsidy of $1.50 a slice: quantity rises to 70 thousand, buyers pay $3.00 and sellers receive $4.50. It costs the government $1.50 × 70 = $105 thousand, a cost of the policy as tax revenue was a gain.
Consumer surplus rises to $245 and producer surplus to $122.5 thousand: together $97.5 thousand more, less than the $105 thousand spent. The gap, $7.5 thousand, is the deadweight loss: the slices past 60 cost more to make than buyers value them.
A quota of 40 thousand slices: buyers bid the price up to $6.00, the price at which they want only 40; sellers would supply that many for $3.00. The gap times the quantity, $120 thousand, goes to whoever holds the right to sell, as quota rent. The deadweight loss is $30 thousand, the same as the $3.00 tax’s, since it cuts the same slices.
| consumer surplus | producer surplus | government | deadweight loss | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| subsidy | $245 | $122.5 | −$105 | $7.5 |
| quota | $80 | $40 | – | $30 |
AP asks what a quota does to quantity, price and surplus; it does not ask you to graph one.
the world price, imports and exports
Opened to trade, a small country takes the world price as given: it can buy or sell any amount at that price. The gap between domestic quantity demanded and supplied is filled by trade.
Closed to trade the pizza market settles at $4.00. Now a world price of $2.00, below it: the domestic price falls to $2.00. Buyers want 80 thousand, domestic sellers make only 20, and the imports are 60 thousand.
With a world price of $5.00, above $4.00, the price rises to it: domestic sellers make 80, buyers take 50, and the country exports 30.
| consumer surplus | producer surplus | government | deadweight loss | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| closed | $180 | $90 | – | – |
| imports at $2.00 | $320 | $10 | – | – |
| exports at $5.00 | $125 | $160 | – | – |
Importing, buyers gain more than domestic sellers lose: total surplus rises from $270 to $330 thousand. Exporting, sellers gain more than buyers lose: $285 thousand. Either way the country as a whole gains, though one side of the market loses. That is why trade policy is fought over.
protecting domestic sellers, at a cost
A tariff is a tax on imports; an import quota is a limit on their quantity. Both raise the domestic price, help domestic sellers, and cost buyers more than they help.
A tariff of $1.00 on the world price of $2.00 raises the domestic price to $3.00. Domestic production rises from 20 to 40; consumption falls from 80 to 70; imports fall from 60 to 30.
| consumer surplus | producer surplus | government | deadweight loss | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| free trade | $320 | $10 | – | – |
| tariff $1.00 | $245 | $40 | +$30 | $15 |
An import quota of 30 thousand would raise the price to the same $3.00, with the same change in quantities and in consumer and total surplus. The difference: the $30 thousand rectangle goes not to the government but to whoever holds the import licenses.
← Basic economic concepts · Production, cost, and the perfect competition model →