Scroll to turn the page
Economics · AP Microeconomics
scarcity, choice and the margin
There is never enough of everything, so every choice gives something up. Microeconomics studies those choices: how people, firms and markets decide what to do with what they have.
The figure shows the tool this whole course runs on. A hypothetical town is deciding how many litter crews to hire. Each extra crew adds less to the town than the last (blue: 50, 40, 30, 20, 10, 5 thousand dollars a month) and costs more (red: 16, 22, 28, 34, 40, 46). Take them one at a time: hire while the extra benefit covers the extra cost. That means 3 crews. The 4th would add $20 thousand and cost $34 thousand.
The chapter builds up to that idea. Resources are scarce, so choosing one thing has an opportunity cost, drawn as a production possibilities curve. Different producers have different opportunity costs, so they gain by specializing and trading. And a rational decision weighs costs against benefits, at the margin: one more crew, one more taco, one more dollar.
This is Unit 1 of AP Microeconomics, 12–15% of the multiple-choice section. Every later unit uses its marginal rule: firms produce where marginal revenue equals marginal cost (Units 3 and 4), hire where the marginal revenue product of a worker equals the marginal resource cost (Unit 5), and society is best off where marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost (Unit 6).
limited resources, unlimited wants
Scarcity: society’s wants and needs are greater than the resources available to meet them. Because resources are scarce, using them one way means not using them another. Every choice is a trade-off.
Resources are the factors of production, each paid its own kind of income:
The figure gives a hypothetical town 20 units of resources. Each unit works at the bakery or the bike works, never both: move one to bicycles (red) and bread falls. Whatever the split, output never reaches what people want (gray): 36 thousand loaves and 8 hundred bicycles, when the most the town can make is 25 and 5.
Most factors are scarce, but not every resource is. The recipe for bread is established knowledge: the bakery using it leaves all of it for the bike works and everyone else. Knowledge is non-rival, so it need not be scarce. The blue sheet sits in both shops at once.
what, how and for whom
Scarce resources have to be allocated. Every society answers three questions: what goods and services to produce, how to produce them, and who consumes them.
The answers depend on its economic system. Each system has its own institutions, and its own way of coordinating who does what with the resources and who gets the output:
In the figure, each bar is one of the three questions: gray where a plan answers it, blue where prices do. The red marker moves from command to market. In the mixed economy the bars differ: a government that redistributes income keeps more of ‘for whom’ for itself than ‘how’.
The rest of this course studies how markets answer the three questions, and when they answer them badly (Unit 6).
opportunity cost, drawn
The opportunity cost of a choice is the value of the next best alternative given up. A production possibilities curve (PPC) shows the trade-off between two goods.
The PPC shows the most an economy can make of two goods when all its resources are used, with its resources and technology fixed. The town’s, in hundreds of bicycles and thousands of loaves a week:
| point | A | B | C | D | E | F |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| bicycles (hundreds) | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
| bread (thousand loaves) | 25 | 24 | 21 | 16 | 9 | 0 |
| bread given up | – | 1 | 3 | 5 | 7 | 9 |
Moving from C to D gains 1 hundred bicycles and costs 21 − 16 = 5 thousand loaves. That bread is the opportunity cost of the bicycles. Going back from D to C, each thousand loaves costs 1/5 of a hundred bicycles, that is 20 bicycles. Each opportunity cost is the reciprocal of the other.
The figure draws each step: blue, one hundred more bicycles; red, the bread given up. Between two points the opportunity cost is the slope of the curve, without its minus sign: the change on the vertical axis per unit on the horizontal.
Opportunity cost need not be money. Choosing more of one good means having less of the other, so even a free choice has a cost. Points on the curve show scarcity: the town can’t have more of both.
on, inside and outside the curve
Where a point lies against the PPC says how well the economy uses its resources.
Points on the curve are all productively efficient, but not equally wanted. The point that makes the combination society values most is allocatively efficient. The PPC alone can’t say which one that is: that takes what people want, which markets reveal (Unit 2).
A rise in unemployment moves the economy inside its PPC; it does not shift the curve. The resources are still there, just idle.
constant, increasing or decreasing cost
The shape of a PPC shows how its opportunity costs change: constant, increasing or decreasing.
The figure draws three economies that can each make 25 thousand loaves or 5 hundred bicycles, and every point is walked one step at a time:
| bread given up for each 100 bicycles | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| constant cost | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 |
| increasing cost | 1 | 3 | 5 | 7 | 9 |
| decreasing cost | 9 | 7 | 5 | 3 | 1 |
To read the shape, compute the opportunity cost of each step from the table. If the steps are equal, the PPC is straight; if they grow, it bows out; if they shrink, it bows in.
shifting the curve
Economic growth is an outward shift of the PPC: the economy can make more of both goods. A shift inward is a contraction.
The PPC is drawn for given factors of production and technology, so only a change in them shifts it:
Not shifters: unemployment (a point inside the curve), and a change in what people want (a move along it).
Today’s choice moves tomorrow’s curve. An economy that makes more capital goods (machines, tools, buildings) and fewer consumer goods now gives up some consumption today, but its PPC shifts out further later.
who should make what
A producer has an absolute advantage in a good when it can make more of it than another producer with the same resources. It has a comparative advantage when it can make the good at a lower opportunity cost.
Two hypothetical countries, each with the same quantity of resources, put all of them into one good (an output table):
| tons, all resources on one good | corn | steel |
|---|---|---|
| Alta | 80 | 40 |
| Bora | 30 | 30 |
Alta has the absolute advantage in both: 80 tons of corn to Bora’s 30, and 40 of steel to 30. That does not settle who should make what. Opportunity costs do. Alta gives up 40 steel for 80 corn, so 1 ton of corn costs it 40/80 = 0.5 ton of steel. With output numbers, divide the other good by the good you are pricing.
| opportunity cost | of 1 ton of corn | of 1 ton of steel |
|---|---|---|
| Alta | 0.5 steel | 2 corn |
| Bora | 1 steel | 1 corn |
Corn is cheaper in Alta (0.5 steel against 1): Alta has the comparative advantage in corn. Steel is cheaper in Bora (1 corn against 2): Bora has it in steel, even though Alta makes more steel. The two opportunity costs of a country are reciprocals, so unless their costs are equal, each country has the comparative advantage in one good.
When a table gives inputs instead (hours or workers to make one unit), fewer hours is the absolute advantage, and the opportunity cost of a good is its own hours divided by the other good’s hours.
specialize, trade, and consume beyond the curve
When each producer specializes in the good of its comparative advantage, and they trade on terms between their opportunity costs, both can consume beyond their own PPC.
Without trade, each country consumes what it makes, a point on its own PPC: Alta (60, 10) and Bora (15, 15), corn first. Together: 75 tons of corn and 25 of steel.
Now Alta makes only corn (80) and Bora only steel (30): more of both in total. Alta ships 16 tons of corn and gets 12 tons of steel back, 0.75 steel per ton of corn.
| without trade | with trade | gain | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alta | 60 corn, 10 steel | 64 corn, 12 steel | +4 corn, +2 steel |
| Bora | 15 corn, 15 steel | 16 corn, 18 steel | +1 corn, +3 steel |
Both end beyond their own PPC. With 12 tons of steel, Alta on its own could have had only 56 tons of corn, not 64. With 18 steel, Bora could have had 12 corn, not 16.
The terms of trade must lie between the two opportunity costs, here between 0.5 and 1 ton of steel per ton of corn. At 0.75, Alta gets more steel for its corn than the 0.5 it would have given up to make that steel, and Bora pays less than the 1 it would have given up to grow the corn. Outside that range, one side would rather make the good itself, and there is no deal.
the full opportunity cost of a choice
The economic cost of a choice is its whole opportunity cost: the explicit costs paid in money, plus the implicit costs of what is given up, though no money changes hands.
Sam, a hypothetical student, is deciding whether to go to a concert. The ticket is $60 and the ride there and back $15: $75 of explicit costs. To go, he would also have to skip a shift at work that pays $70. That pay is an implicit cost: he never hands it over, but he gives it up all the same.
The concert is worth $120 to him: the most he would pay to go.
A rational decision maker counts both kinds of cost. A firm’s implicit costs include the salary its owner gives up to run it and the interest its owner’s own money could earn elsewhere.
On the benefit side, a consumer’s total benefit is measured as utility, the satisfaction from consuming (1.6). A firm’s is its total revenue.
the optimal choice maximizes net benefit
The best choice makes total net benefit, total benefit minus total cost, as large as it can be.
The town’s litter crews again, in thousands of dollars a month:
| crews | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| total benefit | 0 | 50 | 90 | 120 | 140 | 150 | 155 |
| total cost | 0 | 16 | 38 | 66 | 100 | 140 | 186 |
| net benefit | 0 | 34 | 52 | 54 | 40 | 10 | −31 |
Net benefit rises to $54 thousand at 3 crews and then falls: at 4 crews the benefit is larger (140), but the cost has grown more. 3 crews is the optimal choice. It is not the choice with the largest total benefit (that is 6 crews), nor the one with the lowest cost (none).
In the figure, blue is total benefit, red total cost; the black rod is the gap between them, and the bars on the right are that gap at each number of crews.
Hiring can be done a crew at a time, so the same answer comes from comparing one crew at a time (1.6). Some decisions can’t be split into increments: a bridge is built or it is not. Then compare totals. A bridge worth $900 thousand to the town that costs $700 thousand should be built: net benefit $200 thousand.
diminishing marginal utility
Utility is the satisfaction a consumer gets from consuming. Total utility (TU) is from all the units; marginal utility (MU) is the extra from one more unit: MU = ΔTU ÷ ΔQ.
Jo, a hypothetical consumer, eats tacos. Utility is counted in made-up units, utils:
| tacos | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| total utility | 0 | 24 | 44 | 60 | 72 | 80 | 84 | 84 | 80 |
| marginal utility | – | 24 | 20 | 16 | 12 | 8 | 4 | 0 | −4 |
Each taco adds less than the one before: diminishing marginal utility. The first, eaten hungry, adds 24 utils; the fourth, 12. That holds for almost everything people consume, and it is one reason a demand curve slopes down: buyers pay less for more.
Total utility keeps rising as long as MU is positive, just more slowly each time, as the steps in the figure show. It reaches its top, 84, at 6 tacos; the 7th adds 0, and the 8th takes 4 away (red). Total utility is greatest where marginal utility falls to zero.
So if tacos were free, Jo would stop at 6. They aren’t free: each costs money that could buy something else. The next two pages put a price on them.
marginal utility per dollar
A consumer with limited income gets the most utility by spending each dollar where it adds the most: on the good with the highest marginal utility per dollar, MU ÷ P.
The theory of consumer choice assumes consumers are rational: they aim to make their total utility as large as possible, given constraints they can’t change, their income and the prices they face. And their marginal utility diminishes.
Jo has $24. Tacos cost $2, smoothies $4:
| unit | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MU of tacos | 24 | 20 | 16 | 12 | 8 | 4 |
| MU per $ (÷ 2) | 12 | 10 | 8 | 6 | 4 | 2 |
| MU of smoothies | 60 | 44 | 36 | 24 | 16 | 8 |
| MU per $ (÷ 4) | 15 | 11 | 9 | 6 | 4 | 2 |
Comparing marginal utilities alone would be a mistake: the first smoothie gives 60 utils, but it costs twice as much as a taco. Per dollar, it gives 15.
So Jo spends unit by unit, always on the higher MU per dollar: smoothie 1 (15, $4), taco 1 (12, $6), smoothie 2 (11, $10), taco 2 (10, $12), smoothie 3 (9, $16), taco 3 (8, $18), taco 4 (6, $20), smoothie 4 (6, $24). Each step is drawn in the figure; the red bar is the budget spent. After the 8th purchase the $24 is gone, at 4 tacos and 4 smoothies.
The first taco comes second, though its 24 utils are fewer than the second smoothie’s 44: per dollar, 12 beats 11.
MU per dollar equal across goods
Total utility is greatest when all income is spent and the marginal utility per dollar of the last unit is the same for every good:
MUx / Px = MUy / Py, with Px × Qx + Py × Qy = income.
Jo ends at 4 tacos and 4 smoothies. The last taco: 12 ÷ 2 = 6. The last smoothie: 24 ÷ 4 = 6. Equal (the black line in the figure). Spending: 4 × $2 + 4 × $4 = $24, all of it. Total utility: 72 + 164 = 236.
Every other way of spending exactly $24 gives less. 6 tacos and 3 smoothies give 224; 2 tacos and 5 smoothies give 224.
When the ratios are not equal, move spending toward the good with the higher MU per dollar. At 2 tacos and 5 smoothies, the last taco gives 10 per dollar and the last smoothie 4. Giving up that smoothie loses 16 utils and frees $4, enough for two more tacos worth 16 + 12 = 28. Buying more tacos lowers their MU; buying fewer smoothies raises theirs, until the two are equal.
If MUx/Px > MUy/Py: buy more x and less y. The rule also gives the law of demand: a lower price of tacos raises their MU per dollar, so Jo buys more of them.
marginal benefit and marginal cost
Marginal analysis compares the extra benefit of doing a little more of something with the extra cost. Do more while marginal benefit (MB) is greater than marginal cost (MC); do less if MB is less than MC; stop where they are equal.
| crew | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| marginal benefit | 50 | 40 | 30 | 20 | 10 | 5 |
| marginal cost | 16 | 22 | 28 | 34 | 40 | 46 |
Crew 1 adds $50 thousand of benefit for $16 thousand of cost: hire. Crews 2 and 3 also cover their cost. Crew 4 would add $20 thousand for $34 thousand: it lowers net benefit by $14 thousand. So stop at 3, the same answer as the totals gave (1.5), where net benefit was greatest.
With smooth curves the optimum is where MB = MC exactly. In a table, take every unit whose MB is at least its MC and stop before the first that fails.
Each step’s MB is the change in total benefit, and each MC the change in total cost: 120 − 90 = 30, 66 − 38 = 28. When something costs nothing at the margin, MC = 0, so the rule says go on until MB = 0, where total benefit is greatest, as with Jo’s free tacos.
This is how a rational person, firm or government decides whether to increase, decrease or keep an activity where it is.
what is already spent doesn’t change the margin
The optimal quantity does not depend on sunk costs, fixed costs already paid that no choice now can change, or on fixed benefits already decided by past choices.
Suppose the town has already bought a truck for the crews, $30 thousand, and can’t get the money back. Every total cost in the table rises by $30 thousand, and every net benefit falls by the same amount:
| crews | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| net benefit before | 0 | 34 | 52 | 54 | 40 | 10 | −31 |
| after the truck | −30 | 4 | 22 | 24 | 10 | −20 | −61 |
The best number of crews is still 3. The truck adds nothing to the cost of one more crew, so no marginal cost changes, and no marginal benefit either. In the figure the total-cost line lifts by $30 thousand, parallel to itself; the bars all sink, and the tallest is still at 3.
The sunk cost fallacy is letting money already spent drive a decision: staying through a bad movie because the ticket was paid for, or a firm pouring more into a failing project because so much has gone in already. The ticket is gone either way; only what comes next can change.